When I was accepted into the Peace Corps, my position was designated as “education volunteer”. And while I do work at a school and engage in a good deal of educational work, one of the things you find in the Peace Corps is that you must become a jack of all trades – manager as well as chief cook and bottle washer, all at the same time. You find yourself becoming something very different from what you expected and from what you were back home in the States. One thing I certainly never expected, though, was that I would be filling the role of environmentalist.
Outside of the Austin enclave, I think it’s fair to say that Texas and Texans are not known for their environmental sensibilities. And to be quite honest, I am one of those “non-green” Texans. I always looked somewhat askance at what I considered to be the crazy antics of the derisively-termed tree-huggers. I also had a thorough distaste for what I saw as the aggressive agenda of the greenies - people who seemed to want to impose their hippie beliefs on the rest of us. These views have not entirely changed, and I do still find suspicious, unrealistic, and economically naive a good number of the views and policies of the green contingent.
One of the things I have found from my experience in the Peace Corps, though, is that experiencing on a large scale, behaviour that is otherwise seen as harmless or trivial, causes you to move radically in the other direction. The best example in my case is punctuality. As any of my friends and family will tell you, I was serially late in my life in America. I was always the guy who people were waiting on, consistently arriving 10-20 minutes late. Having lived for a year now, though, in a country engulfed in “African time” in which people show up whenever they feel like it, I have become decidedly rigid on time, usually ensuring that I am early to whatever appointment or engagement I have made. Seeing the problems and experiencing the frustration caused by a society in which everyone is late, often by 1 hour or more, has made me realize the great value of punctuality.
The same can also be said for alcohol. I enjoy drinking, but living in a place drowning in alcoholism and constant, irresponsible consumption, has definitely made me temper my habits a bit. This further extends to the topic of my post today, which is that of littering.
The place where I live is, to put it bluntly, absolutely filthy. Trash (or “rubbish” in South African parlance) is literally everywhere. It is in the schoolyard, in the streets, and even outside of the local government buildings. The landscape is strewn with potato chip bags, broken beer bottles, and used tissue paper. You simply cannot look around without finding some form of litter on the ground.
I know some people who have witnessed or heard about this situation have suggested that it might be a result of lack of trash cans (“rubbish bins”). The idea is that there simply is not a container readily available in which to deposit the refuse and so people, not having anywhere else to put the stuff, toss it to the floor. It is true that trash cans are not nearly as prevalent as they are in America, and I, not wanting to be judgmental, wanted to believe this explanation, too. Unfortunately, I have found from repeated experience, that even when a trash can is located only a few feet away, the students (and residents of the township, in general) will still chuck the garbage on the ground without thinking twice. When asked why they don’t use the container, they respond with a mixture of confusion and annoyance as to why one would suggest such a thing. The result is that the entire area resembles a landfill.
This puts me in one of the dicey predicaments, encountered quite often here, where you have to weigh the idea of universal values vs. culture. For those who are unaware, the slogan “Don’t Mess with Texas” was actually originally part of an anti-littering campaign. It has, of course, now morphed into a globally acknowledged expression of the general Texas attitude, but for me remains a truism - that to litter is to disrespect our beautiful Lone Star State which I will always call my home. As a result, you will never find me chucking stuff on the ground, especially if it is not biodegradable. This is for a guy who, as I mentioned above, is by no means an environmentalist. I would like to think that as an independent-minded adult, I choose this behaviour on the basis of my own personal, logical analysis. If I am to be quite honest, though, it is probably more because I had the idea beaten into my head since birth that you simply do not litter.
That attitude, however, does not seem to exist here. Most Black South Africans do not seem to be bothered by the trash that is ever-present. (I do not enjoy making racial distinctions like this, but in my experience, White South Africans do not engage in littering on near such a scale.) I find this to be somewhat ironic given that people many times speak of Africans’ connection to the land, and the importance it plays in their culture and religion. Such a bond to the earth does not seem to prevent them from treating the land as their wastebasket, though, and this includes township residents and rural villagers, alike. Holding onto refuse until an appropriate bin is found is seen as needless effort. I have come to believe that the paeans written to native people and their respect for the land are actually somewhat wrong-headed. In my opinion, the land inhabited by natives which was found by the earliest explorers and settlers was often not clean and well cared for because of conscious choice by the original residents but rather because the aboriginal people did not produce many things that did not quickly disintegrate or rot away. What is often hailed as conservation was, I think, sometimes simply a low level of production.
Regardless of this apparent inconsistency between respect for land and casual disposal of trash, the fact remains that it is SOUTH AFRICANS’ land. The question I must ask myself then is: If their mindset is different, who am I, as a White foreigner, to tell them differently? Is it not a bit presumptuous of me to tell them they are wrong and need to adopt MY values? These are the kinds of dilemmas that one encounters as a Peace Corps volunteer. At what point does development and aid become imperialism and self-righteousness? (It also is not lost on me that the same guy who did not appreciate hippies telling him he should act a certain way is now doing the same thing to others.)
In this case, though, I think I do have reason on my side. The government of South Africa has stated it is committed to green practices and includes measures relating to this in much of its legislation. In fact, the most recent summit on global warming was held in the town of Durban on the eastern coast of South Africa. Littering is decidedly at odds with these goals, and if the popularly elected government promotes this, no one can say that is only MY values I am preaching. Not to mention, there ARE some very negative consequences that result from littering, making rubbish disposal a practical matter as well.
Practical matters aside, though, the thing that I truly fail to understand is how a good number of Black South Africans, both young and old, seem to not mind the aesthetic effect of the presence of trash all around. To me, it is just plain UGLY. I don’t want my home to look like that. I don’t throw my trash on the ground, and even when I see things on the ground that I didn’t put there, I pick them up and throw them away. I keep my surroundings clean as a matter of pride. In my mind, I take ownership of my area. It is MY place, and I want MY place to look nice. My fellow residents of Ikhutseng, however, do not share that emotion.
I do not know why so many Black South Africans do not have that same feeling of pride. People will perhaps adduce apartheid and poverty as the reason. Perhaps. To me, though, the reason is not so important as the way forward. Low economic and social station are not impenetrable barriers to good environmental stewardship. On the contrary. When you have little, I think it is even more important that you take pride in that small amount that you do have. It is through such pride in what you have that you learn to value other resources as well. My mother grew up in a family that very much struggled with money in my mother’s early years yet my maternal grandmother always told my mom that regardless of how much money you have, you can always be clean. They took this as a point of pride amidst their lack of things, and that has stuck with my mom until today. I think those are good words to live by. Regardless of your situation, you can always strive to be clean both personally AND environmentally.
So, at the risk of having Texas copyright lawyers hunt me down, let me end by saying:
Please, please, please – DON’T MESS WITH SOUTH AFRICA.
South African English Word of the Day
Sharp (pronounced “shop”) – good; ok; alright
Guy 1: Everything is ready for our trip.
Guy 2: Sharp!